Circle customer avatarsStar rating

70k+ reviews

Your newsletter built the audience. Circle helps you build the business.

Your members are already paying. Give them somewhere to connect, learn, and keep coming back to — not just an inbox to check.

A real community where members connect — not a flat thread list
One platform for courses, events, email, payments, and more
AI and workflows that do the retention work you’d otherwise hire for
The Circle platform

Trusted by more than 15 million members across 20,000 communities

Ali Abdaal
Ali Abdaal6.5M subscribers
English with Lucy
English with Lucy12.9M subscribers
Tim Ferriss
Tim Ferriss500K monthly listeners
Ness Labs
Ness Labs100K readers
Jay Shetty
Jay Shetty900K readers
The Futur
The Futur2.7M subscribers

Substack was built to broadcast content, not run a business

Substack limits you to one-way communication

Substack — one-way content broadcasting

Circle’s complete community platform actually helps you grow

Circle — the complete community platform

Substack users are switching to Circle to build real community businesses every day

Tiago Forte photo

We’ve made over $3M on Circle over the last two years. It supported our live cohorts, self-paced courses, virtual summits, a subscription-based membership, and our first in-person summit in LA. This is the power of a true ‘all-in-one’ platform.

Tiago Forte community logo

Tiago ForteFounder, Forte Labs

You’re ready for Circle if this sounds like you

Your members pay every month and have nowhere to actually connect with each other

Your posts are a long, flat feed with no spaces, no structure, no way to organize anything

You want to offer a course, but Substack has no course builder

You’re paying 10% to Substack and still buying three other tools to run your business

Your brand lives inside Substack’s app, competing for attention alongside thousands of other newsletters

Circle community spaces and engagement features

Build a community that becomes the reason members stay

Give members structured spaces, live interaction, and learning paths that make them feel invested, not just subscribed.

Features
Circle
Substack
Structured spaces and access groups
Member connection recommendations
Direct messaging between members
Community-specific activity and discussion feeds
Drag-and-drop course builder
Live events with RSVP, ticketing, recordings, and gated replays
Gamification — points, leaderboards, badges
Circle all-in-one platform

Run an entire member business from one platform, not five tools

Community, courses, events, email, and more. All native. No integrations to manage, no data scattered across platforms.

Features
Circle
Substack
Custom domain
Website builder with custom pages
Email Hub with community-behavior triggers
Payments — one-time, subscription, installment
Analytics across community, courses, and events
Member CRM with customer profile fields
Circle AI and workflow automation

Scale your growth without scaling your workload

Automation to handle onboarding, follow-ups, and re-engagement. AI to handle questions and moderation. You focus on the work that matters.

Features
Circle
Substack
Conditional and branching workflows
Community-behavior communication triggers
Activity scoring of members
AI agents with distinct roles and placement controls
AI inbox (visibility into AI interactions)
Mobile app and desktop app, with notifications

The complete community platform

Circle is the best platform to build, engage, and scale your business

Circle AI
Community
Chat
CRM
Events
Live
Courses
AI Agents
Email Marketing
Payments
Website Builder

Circle moves fast — so you can grow even faster

Industry-leading product velocity, support, and customer ratings make Circle the most trusted platform for serious community and creator businesses.

Upgrade from Substack to Circle in three steps

Let our migration team handle the heavy lifting—so you don’t have to.

1

Request your migration

Fill out a quick form to tell us about your setup. We’ll take it from there. We’ll migrate your:

  1. Courses
  2. Email list
  3. Memberships
  4. And more
2

Approve your custom plan

We’ll create a tailored migration plan based on your needs. You review and approve before we begin.

3

Sit back while we migrate

Our team moves everything over—content, members, settings—fully structured and ready to go live.

Leader on G2

Trusted by 20,000+ businesses to power their communities

G2 Leader
G2 Leader Small Business
G2 Best Usability
G2 Most Implementable
G2 Best Results

Frequently asked questions

Generally, no. At low revenue, Substack’s 10% cut of the revenue you earn looks affordable. But as you scale:

  • Paying 10% becomes a larger figure.
  • You’ll inevitably buy and integrate more tools to offer discussions, courses, and more to your members.

On the other hand, Circle charges:

  • $89 per month for the Professional plan, plus a 2% transaction fee.
  • $199 per month for the Business plan, plus a 1% transaction fee.
  • A custom price for Circle Plus, plus a 0.5% transaction fee.

So, if you’re earning more than $1,500 per month on Substack, you’ll ultimately pay less for Circle.

You can learn more by using our community ROI calculator or exploring our pricing page.

Still can’t find the answer? Go to help center

Test what a real, complete community platform feels like for yourself